Punditish  
 Punditish Home Page More Entries   Blogroll   Categories   Email  
Podhoretz-casting the First Stone
Yeah, I know, it's a stretch.

John Podhoretz has seen the new Star Wars movie, and doesn't think much of it:

John Podhoretz - May 10th, 2005
It opens next week. I saw it, and here's the thing: It's unbelievably bad. O I'm telling you this because movie critics won't. So far all the early reviews -- all of them, from Variety to the Hollywood Reporter to Time magazine -- have been favorable. Why? Because while the movie critics of my long-ago youth were middlebrow snobs suspicious of populist entertainment, today's critics have turned into toadies. They are afraid of being on an audience's bad side, afraid that a movie they will pan might really strike a chord. Since it's a foregone conclusion that the final Star Wars is going to make a jillion dollars, the safe thing for critics to do is say nice things about it.

Podhoretz is entitled to his opinion, but his reasoning is bunk; critics were split just about 60/40 in favor of Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace. Those 40% or so registered their dissatisfaction despite knowing that that film, too, would make a "jillion dollars." And this is leaving aside the fact that many of the positive reviews were still less than glowing; good, but not Star Wars good, was the consensus.

Regardless, the fact that he didn't even like Attack of the Clones is reason enough to disregard this opinion. Chalk up another silly victory for nostalgia.

   »  May 10th, 2005





         Calendar


More Entries
» Selective Forgiveness
» "The Capacity to Be Outraged"
» Busting McCain Memes
» The Kodak Theatre Debate
» Hugh Hewitt Didn't Major in Mathematics
» The California Debate
» Reflections on the Rallies
» The Ironic Prescience of Matchbox 20
» McCain Wins Florida
» The Case for McCain



Blogroll
  • Instapundit
  • Andrew Sullivan
  • Tom Maguire
  • Decision '08
  • Patrick O'Keefe



    Categories
  • Blogging
  • Democrats
  • Economy
  • Elections '04
  • Elections '06
  • Elections '08
  • Entertainment
  • George W. Bush
  • Iraq
  • Media
  • Miscellaneous
  • Republicans
  • Social Security
  • Supreme Court
  • Technology
  • War on Terror



    Email Me
    Email Punditish
  •  Punditish Home Page More Entries   Blogroll   Categories   Email