Punditish  
 Punditish Home Page More Entries   Blogroll   Categories   Email  
Iraq

March 28th, 2005...

Drudge: "al-Zarqawi is surrounded"
Drudge is tenatively reporting that Abu Musab al-Zarqawi has been surrounded. He is apparently quoting Iraqi Interior Minister Falah al-Nakib.

This isn't being echoed on CNN, Fox News, MSNBC, or Yahoo! News yet, but apparently it's making the rounds on some radio already.

Cautious optimism is still the order of the day; we've had false reports of Zarqawi's capture before. Let's hope this one is true, because given the elections and the subsequently demoralized insurgency, this could very well be the back-breaker.

UPDATE: apparently Fox News was talking about the implications of the capture, if it is indeed true, but held off on confirming it. Drudge, for the time being, has removed it. We'll just have to wait and see.

   »  Permalink





March 25th, 2005...

I've Got Your "Exit Strategy" Right Here
From the Financial Times:

Steve Negus - March 25th, 2005
Many of Iraq's predominantly Sunni Arab insurgents would lay down their arms and join the political process in exchange for guarantees of their safety and that of their co-religionists, according to a prominent Sunni politician.

Sharif Ali Bin al-Hussein, who heads Iraq's main monarchist movement and is in contact with guerrilla leaders, said many insurgents including former officials of the ruling Ba'ath party, army officers, and Islamists have been searching for a way to end their campaign against US troops and Iraqi government forces since the January 30 election.

This probably isn't the kind of exit strategy Ted Kennedy had in mind.

   »  Permalink





March 16th, 2005...

Worst. Timing. Ever.
According to a poll conducted by the International Republican Institute, Iraqis believe their country is headed in the right direction by a 62% to 23% margin, the most positive result in the seven polls the group has done.

Meanwhile, in an action that could cause the universe to implode in a fit of raw irony, anti-war protestors have planned another march (or something) for Saturday, March 19th; the 2nd anniversary of the war's beginning.

   »  Permalink





March 15th, 2005...

Looting the Weapons Iraq Never Had
According to the New York Times "looters systematically dismantled and removed tons of machinery from Saddam Hussein's most important weapons installations" in the "weeks after Baghdad fell in April 2003."

Let's keep in mind, of course, that to the degree these weapons are dangerous it justifies invasion to the same degree. One cannot claim Saddam as having been harmless, yet also point to the dispersal of these weapons as a setback in the War on Terror, if only because there was nothing to prevent Saddam from dispersing them beforehand; and on an ongoing basis, too.

Christopher Hitchens -- one of the war's more eloquent supporters -- sees this contradiction in complaints, and has some harsh words for postwar planning, as well.

   »  Permalink





February 22nd, 2005...

Define the Word "Worked"
A little late for a fisking, perhaps, but I felt compelled to note this entry from Daily Kos on Iraqi sanctions. Here's a short quote:

Markos Moulitsas - February 14th, 2005
That's one of the tragedies of this senseless-war (out of so, so many) -- the UN sanctions actually worked. Watch the wingers and their enablers in the corporate media try to obfuscate that point.

Kos quotes David Kay to confirm the idea that Iraq wasn't making much progress in developing weapons and, from this, he draws the conclusion that the sanctions were "working," though you'd have to use a rather narrow definition of the word to make that claim.

Consider, for example, that the sanctions clearly hurt the Iraqi people, and that the UN's attempt to compensate for this, the scandal-ridden Oil-For-Food program, did little to help, and much to enrich Saddam. Toss in the fact that he wasn't shy about offering lump sums to the families of Palestinian suicide bombers, and sanctions were indirectly funding terrorism.

And what of Osama bin Laden's 1998 fatwa wherein he urges jihad against Americans and cites the "Americans' continuing aggression against the Iraqi people" and the "protracted blockade" imposed on Iraq among his reasons?

A solution which causes a slew of other (sometimes worse) problems is not one which has genuinely "worked."

   »  Permalink





What Happened to the Puppet Regime Claim?
From the Associated Press, courtesy of Yahoo! News:

Maggie Michael - February 22nd, 2005
Interim Iraqi Vice President Ibrahim al-Jaafari was chosen as his Shiite ticket's candidate for prime minister Tuesday after Ahmad Chalabi dropped his bid, senior alliance officials said.

Al-Jaafari's selection means he likely will lead Iraq's first democratically elected government in 50 years. But first he has to be approved by a coalition that likely will include the Kurds, and then he must be approved by a majority of the newly elected National Assembly.

Pressure from within the ranks of the United Iraqi Alliance, which won Iraq's landmark Jan. 30 election, forced the withdrawal of Chalabi, a one-time Pentagon favorite, said Hussein al-Moussawi from the Shiite Political Council, an umbrella group for 38 Shiite parties.

This brings the opposition arguments full circle; first it was "the US is just going to impose some puppet regime on the Iraqis." Not having come to pass, that claim has been replaced by "hey look, the administration is so incompetent they couldn't get their puppet elected and have therefore lost control of Iraq." Nevermind that whole period of intellectual reflection that would typically follow a bold prediction falling on its face.

   »  Permalink





February 18th, 2005...

Since When Was It Operation: Find WMDs?
A popular meme amongst the anti-war crowd these days is that the recent democratic triumph in Iraq is merely a serendipitous consequence of an unjustified invasion. WMDs, they say, were what sold everyone on the war (nevermind that most of them opposed it even then), and all this talk about invading to spread "freedom" is rewriting history.

If those taking this stance won't do the basic research required to stumble across the truth, I guess we'll have to put it in their path for them. I hope they're wearing kneepads.

Ahem:

George W. Bush - January 28th, 2003 (SOTU)
And tonight I have a message for the brave and oppressed people of Iraq: Your enemy is not surrounding your country -- your enemy is ruling your country. (Applause.) And the day he and his regime are removed from power will be the day of your liberation. (Applause.)

...

And as we and our coalition partners are doing in Afghanistan, we will bring to the Iraqi people food and medicines and supplies -- and freedom. (Applause.)

More:

George W. Bush - February 10th, 2003
And there's no doubt in my mind, when the United States acts abroad and home, we do so based upon values -- particularly the value that we hold dear to our hearts, and that is, everybody ought to be free. I want to repeat what I said during my State of the Union to you. Liberty is not America's gift to the world. What we believe strongly, and what we hold dear, is liberty is God's gift to mankind.

And it keeps on comin':

George W. Bush - March 16th, 2003
Action to remove the threat from Iraq would also allow the Iraqi people to build a better future for their society. And Iraq's liberation would be the beginning, not the end, of our commitment to its people.

This entry would be long indeed if I reproduced all such quotes I found after a mere five-to-ten minutes of searching around the White House's news archives. He hit on these themes time after time, in an address to the nation, a radio address, remarks from the Rose Garden, and, of course, in his message to the Iraqi people.

If that isn't enough, let's not forget that the invasion itself was titled Operation: Iraqi Freedom for crying out loud.

Hats off to Norman Geras for making this point before me this morning, and more eloquently at that.

   »  Permalink





         Calendar


More Entries
» Selective Forgiveness
» "The Capacity to Be Outraged"
» Busting McCain Memes
» The Kodak Theatre Debate
» Hugh Hewitt Didn't Major in Mathematics
» The California Debate
» Reflections on the Rallies
» The Ironic Prescience of Matchbox 20
» McCain Wins Florida
» The Case for McCain



Blogroll
  • Instapundit
  • Andrew Sullivan
  • Tom Maguire
  • Decision '08
  • Patrick O'Keefe



    Categories
  • Blogging
  • Democrats
  • Economy
  • Elections '04
  • Elections '06
  • Elections '08
  • Entertainment
  • George W. Bush
  • Iraq
  • Media
  • Miscellaneous
  • Republicans
  • Social Security
  • Supreme Court
  • Technology
  • War on Terror



    Email Me
    Email Punditish
  •  Punditish Home Page More Entries   Blogroll   Categories   Email